Was There More To The Turner Gill Firing Than On Field Performance?
A non competitive 2-10 record and a winless conference record would have provided more than enough reason for most fans to part ways with Turner Gill. But in the aftermath of Gill's departure it's becoming clear that accountability seems to have been a major issue within the Kansas Jayhawk program during GIll's brief two year tenure and it makes you wonder if that gave Sheahon Zenger all the more reason to make the call just two years into a five year guarantee.
First and foremost there was the well known issue within the strength and conditioning program. It was talked about after year one and it was supposed to be addressed heading into year two. From the sound of things that never happened. Almost immediately after the first workout with the new staff players took to social media and appeared to express a noticeable change at the way things appear to be moving going forward. What makes those comments all the more encouraging is that the there is an optimism about that direction and in some, like Daymond Patterson, you can sense that he is hungry for the challenge.
Beyond that there were concerns in the classroom, concerns with off the field behavior and even concerns in terms of eligibility issues that seemed to have led to the dismissal of some players from the team heading into the Spring semester. I do think it's important to distinguish one point and that is that Jordan Webb, Tyrone Sellers, Tom Mabry and Travis Bodenstein CHOSE to move on. That's completely different and they have every right to make that decision when a major change takes place. It seems that in some instances they have bundled in with the six dismissals and that isn't really fair to them.
As for those dismissed, some have taken to social media, some have granted interviews and everyone wants to paint themselves as a victim or the person in the right. Judging anyone on rumor or speculation is a bit pointless so I guess you have to take it for what it's worth and assume the best. In all reality I think many would have liked to see a few of those players on the roster and doing well for themselves and Kansas.
At the same time there are 60+ individuals who didn't seem to have a problem with Kansas or Charlie Weis and I think that's a good thing. Then you have a player like Dayne Crist, who was very well respected at Notre Dame, pointing to Weis's honesty as a huge reason he is now at Kansas.
"The biggest thing that I talked about is honesty. He is not about sending any false vibes or messages. Whatever he says is the truth. That's something that all of the players that played for him at Notre Dame will tell you about him. All of the players that played for him in the NFL and will get to play for him here will all know that whatever he's telling you is the absolute truth. He's intense and he's a competitor.
There are always two sides to every story, and at the end of the day there is bound to be turnover and probably a few bruised ego's when a new staff enters the picture. That turnover will be long forgotten very soon, everyone will move on and hopefully all will find a situation where they can be successful.
The point is that for as good as Gill appears to be as a person, it might be his blind belief in others that sank the ship. Gill wanted players to hold themselves accountable and it just doesn't sound like that was happening across the board. For all the talk of his odd ball rules related to female friends, cussing etc, they were rarely enforced and primarily because they were circumvented with ease. Throw in a lack of consequences and it just wasn't a recipe for success at the University of Kansas
Kansas hasn't and won't land the overwhelming talent that the Alabama's and Oklahoma's of the world will. But if you have someone who runs a tight ship and challenges the players in a disciplined and organized manner you can maximize your talent. I do believe that Gill challenged people in his way, I do believe Gill can benefit a football program on some level. Gill just did not run a program or challenge his players in a way that was going to work for Kansas football.
51 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Reminds me of Gill's former coach
Remember all the “second chances” that Lawrence Phillips got in Lincoln? I’d rather have a 6-6 team run the right way across the board than a 10-2 one with special treatment for some but not others.
So be it
There’s a right and a wrong way of doing things, and we’re gonna do it the right way. That’s all there is to it.
- Charlie Weis
by jayhawk1996 on Jan 18, 2012 11:19 AM CST up reply actions 1 recs
that won't mean much
if he only get to 6-6 consistently. not saying I necessarily disagree with you, but he has to get to bowl games for the fanbase to by anything close to happy.
Agreed
The bar isn’t as high as many think. We’re talking about a program that’s been to bowls in consecutive years just once in its history. A run of three or four years would be epic.
by jayhawk1996 on Jan 18, 2012 11:30 AM CST up reply actions
I'm quite happy with the pace of this transition!
The flushing of the Gill from the program is movin along MUCH more quickly than the flushing of the Mangino when Gill took over.
Think about it. How many Mangino kids did Gill weed out his first few weeks?
I can only think of Ian Wolfe (quit football I believe), Jose Rodriquez (beat up a dude as a bar bouncher), and Jamal Greene (arrested for felonies).
I may be missing a few others, but the point is I really like the fact that Weis is taking a fast, no-nonsense approach to cleaning house.
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
No
No sarcasm intended. What part do you think I was being sarcastic about?
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
The praise of Weis...
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
It's deserved.
Look, I like the things Coach Weis is saying (and doing) right now. And I’ll give credit where it’s due. But I still think his hiring was a bad choice. And in 2-3 years from now, when Charlie hops to another opportunity and/or decides living 1000s of miles away from his wife and special-needs daughter was a mistake, we’ll find ourselves pretty much right back where we started.
The KU football program is in desperate need of continuity in order to improve it’s national standing and performance. Just my opinion. And I don’t think Coach Weis will provide that needed continuity.
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
If he improves the visibility of the program
and gets the ball rolling (and we’ll have paid off Gill by then) doesn’t that potentially make KU a stronger cantidate to pick up a big name coach?
Wouldn’t it put is roughly in the same spot we were in a few years back when Mangino was let go? If HCCW succeeds if only for 3 years do we immediately revert back to Turner Gill/Terry Allen era football?
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
It does.
But I don’t want to “pick up a big name coach”. The problem I see with that strategy is that a big name coach will just use KU as a stepping stone to another, better gig. I think we’re better off developing the next big-name coach in house and hope that he falls in love with the program he built from the ground up. Even if he doesn’t fall in love, we’ve got a better chance of keeping him around and stabilizing.
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
Wasn't there a 2 million dollar penalty for leaving before the contract is up?
If he leaves after year 2, he would have worked his ass off for $0.
It's not that I'm lazy; it's that I just don't care.
$2.5 million if he terminates it prior to December 31st, 2014 and
$1.5 million if he terminates it prior to December 31st, 2016.
Except, it's rare that a coach actually pays that penalty
Rather, the new gig (school or pro team) will pay that on his behalf.
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
Charlie has said
he wants to end his career right and retire in five years. The only reason for him to leave sooner would be if he wasn’t getting the job done. Do you really expect that?
Assuming he gets the job done, expect him to announce an OC/HC-in-waiting in a year or 3, and the rest of the program/staff will transition right along.
I completely agree with your concern and hope for the program, though I think Charlie has made it pretty clear that he has a different plan than what you project.
by dagger108 on Jan 18, 2012 3:13 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Charlie also said:
“I’m a Florida guy now. That’s why I bought the horse farm. I’m here to stay”.
Ooops.
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
I have said it before
Any coach, Weis or not, who has success at Kansas will leave to greener pastures when the time comes. So I am not sure how Weis is any different in that regard.
It's not that I'm lazy; it's that I just don't care.
No Ooops
Charlie is a Florida guy, and still has the horse. I fully expect him to be sipping lemonade during the week in 6 years, with the ocassional color commentating on the weekends.
For the next 5 years though, I fully expect him to be working “foreign land” not unlike any number of buisness people working for international companies, or military personnel. Some families transplant, while others maintain their “home”. I actually have a number of friends that are doing it both ways. I considered it for a while, though not the Weisian version.
by dagger108 on Jan 18, 2012 10:29 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Yes, that
And the fact that you’ve always talked about the high turnover in the KU football coaching offices.
If guys aren't going to buy into the new staff, you need them gone
No matter how good they are. Some guys were just too in love with Gill, you saw the “NO DONT FIRE GILL THIS IS BS!” guys after it happened.
And there was a reason why. There was no discipline. Gill just preached about stuff and then didn’t enforce a thing.
Point is, we can’t have cancers in the lockerroom. I’d rather we get rid of anyone who is going to be a potential problem now. Especially on offense, where we’ve already added several guys who will start next year and appear to be better than whatever we had there last year.
Shit happens when you win championships
by Andrew Clark on Jan 18, 2012 11:57 AM CST up reply actions
Ying to the Yang
How many people were fleaing the disfunction before MM left. With Gill it was easier to stay in, so a totally different context. There were quite a few players (10-ish? that I seem to remember Owen? meantioning in one post/not article) that left by the time Spring ball rolled around, and a few that Gill didn’t let back on the team.
That being said, I still prefer Charlie’s approach. Make rules and live by them. Let’s all repeat, “Mandatory”.
I think it's evident that there was more than met the eye with Gill's ouster
Clearly he dealt in platitudes with his boys as much as he did with the outside world. I’m so glad Terry Allen 2.0 lasted only 2 years.
BTW, when is the the team’s first trip to Dave and Busters?
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Weis probably eats all the pizza
the players have to fight each other for the uncooked dough and the losers eat the game machines
I write everywhere. You're probably better off following me on twitter
we always said
we wanted a hungry team…
Pay heed...
by pj_hawk4life on Jan 18, 2012 1:49 PM CST up reply actions
Some posters over at KUSports make a good point
the Tweets coming out of yesterday’s conditioning are telling considering the fact that the offseason workout was under 2 hours and they were beat. Shoot, my High School offseason workouts were 2 1/2 hours (albiet probably not as intense) under Bud Wheeler at Olathe South.
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Did you know Kate Finch and Erin Binter perchance?
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Yes.
I was in Chorale with both. Erin was my sister in the musical Kiss Me Kate.
What? A girl who likes sports...INCONCEIVABLE!
Oh yes, Mrs O.
Kate was my GF all thru HS, small world…
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Loved Mrs. O
Both Kate and Erin were the year ahead of me in school. Summer birthday so my parents decided to hold me back.
You dated the same girl all through h.s.? I’m impressed. I got bored after a few months…
What? A girl who likes sports...INCONCEIVABLE!
well, thru senior year
and it was an on again off again kind of thing but yeah. We’re actually still pretty close. Ah, high school.
My brother had Mrs. O at South when he was there. She conducted a couple of honor choirs when I was a kid, I still remember her rather, ah, florid conducting style.
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Never thought I'd see an
Erin Binter reference here at RCT. Bravo, Labba.
Criticize FHOFNCHCBS at your own risk...
by Bensa on Jan 18, 2012 1:19 PM CST up reply actions 1 recs
Erin and I go way back...
I ran into her on the subway a few months back.
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
I bet you'd never see a conducting style reference either...
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
Also, is it true that Gill made it a point
to be home every night at 5:30pm because he was such a devoted family man?
Probably just a rumor but it fits…
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
I would like to point out that
I love talking KU football in January.
The name of that song played at KC Comets games in the '80's was Giorgio Moroder's "The Chase." Now you know.
seconded
I think one thing is for sure, there is going to be a real buzz around Lawrence come August.
by I need more Esteban on Jan 18, 2012 12:56 PM CST up reply actions
Now that the jersey names are taken care of
The obvious next biggest question is whether The Gridiron will continue. Has anybody heard anything about Micah’s relationship with Coach Weis? Will it be a lock-down Patriots/Chiefs type of organization now? Just wondering, thanks for any insight.
Pay heed...
I hope it continues that was the only good thing about the Gill era
It's not that I'm lazy; it's that I just don't care.
If that's true....
then I nominate Olatain Oguntodu’s scene/speech from the GT episode as a RCT Hall of Fame entry.
“don’t be on that Heisman film!”
"No time for questions. No time for games. Start kickin' ass and takin' down the names." - Dave Mustaine.
i hear we have a place to do that
I write everywhere. You're probably better off following me on twitter
Me too....for about 2 weeks.
Then they just got depressing.
www.oreadboomkings.fantake.com
seriously?
I would think that would be an invaluable recruiting tool. Don’t see why they wouldn’t keep it going if Micah wanted to.
One thing is for sure, he’ll get a job somewhere. (KU Film school shout out!)
by I need more Esteban on Jan 18, 2012 5:17 PM CST up reply actions

by 













